Is the “Paradox of Choice” Derailing Your Home Search?

Buying a home for the first time can be confusing. That’s why the tips and strategies you’ll find in my 8-week series will set you on the right path. It’s my own unique approach and a “behind the scenes” glimpse of what you should look out for and consider when starting your own search for a home.

As a buyer do you find yourself “wanting to see everything” in your price range or “needing to look at just one more house or condo”? 

You may truly believe that having a wide selection of homes to choose from is the only way to find one you love. 

But you know what? It’s a proven fact that having too many choices only increases your chance of making the wrong choice! 

One of my favorite books here at Catherine Olive Real Estate is “The Paradox of Choice” by Barry Schwartz.  I often discuss the moral of this book with clients and on occasion give a copy to those who are having a hard time making a choice.

You can apply the principles of this book to any area of your life where you are having a hard time making a decision. However, for today’s lesson I’ll apply it to the home-buying process once I explain the “paradox of choice.”  

Choice Overload 

Research has shown that having too many choices – from selecting a box of cereals to choosing a mutual fund package, or from finding a partner to picking a home – can overwhelm and stress people.  They become confused and reach a point where they feel paralyzed with indecision. 

These buyers also experience an increased feeling of doubt or dissatisfaction once a decision is made. Many can’t get passed the thought that one of the other choices would have been better. 

Has that ever been you? 

Most likely you face an insane number of choices for all sorts of decisions, whether you’re at the grocery store, shopping online, or the car lot. We’re talking about both the big and small purchases in your life!

When there are so many options to choose from, it’s easy to end up in a situation where doing nothing becomes the “default choice.” We’ve all walked out of a store empty handed when this happens. Or decide to delay making a purchase till “another time.”

Why More Is Actually Less

When it comes to house hunting, you do want to have a healthy inventory of listings to view.  However, thinking “seeing more is better” can actually sidetrack your home search. 

More choice can cause confusion, second guessing, and just being overwhelmed.  

For example, if you spend the day (and weeks) looking at so many homes, you can start feeling confused about the features of each one.  Your mind will start going in circles trying to distinguish each home. 

Plus it’s just harder to narrow down your choices and start to eliminate homes when you have viewed way too many. 

Make Choosing Less Stressful 

There are several strategies to make your search successful and satisfying from beginning to end. This means you’ll need to learn how to narrow down your choices.

Sometimes the market itself limits your choices, but you’ll still need to make a decision at some point. Here’s how to do it:

  • Spend time “researching” BEFORE you’re a serious buyer.  Get educated about your local market in terms of price, location and features. Visit open houses, go online, and talk to trusted and reliable friends about how they made their home-buying decision.  This way your expectations are realistic and you’ll be more confident when you do become a serious buyer with an agent. Do your best to keep this time productive and perhaps even with a deadline, but don’t feel rushed or stressed. That way you can move on to becoming a ready buyer, or you’ll still be “looking” two years down the road.
  • Figure out your needs, wants and even your deal breakers. I say this over and over again but it’s SO important to make a well-thought-out list and stick to it. Focus your time and energy on what matters to you.  I recommend starting with what lifestyle you want to live and making your list from there.  
  • Stick with your budget and price range. You’ll increase your doubt, confusion, and dissatisfaction if you start to see homes outside your price range—lower or higher. You’re just adding more choices (and not good ones for you!). You should have already done your research so this action is an unnecessary waste of energy and time once you’re a serious buyer.
  • Compare apples to apples.  It’s not a good idea to compare homes that are in two very different locations – it will only lead to “analysis paralysis”!  For example, a home in the suburbs is most likely going to be bigger and possible newer than a similar priced home in the most desirable location in a more urban area. 

To avoid this from happening, you first need to narrow your location by deciding what lifestyle you want.  However, if you decide to be open to other locations, compare similar homes within the specific location.  

  • Remember having “enough choices” doesn’t mean a large number. Too many choices can be daunting, so you want to aim for “enough” choices. This way you’ll be confident in your decision and satisfied that you’re not shortchanging yourself with too few choices. Work with your agent so that you view “enough” homes that meet your list’s criteria. 
  • Keep eliminating homes and move on. When you view a home, it’s either a “yes” or “no” and then on to the next one. Eliminate as you go along so you can keep your selection to two to three homes. Don’t “keep it in the running” just in case! You’ll end up with too many “maybe’s” to whittle down. Another strategy is to ask yourself what home you like better—the one you are in right now or the ones you just saw.  Then pick your favorite of the day.  
  • Don’t worry you’re missing out. Your agent is there to help pare down the number of homes to view and keep you focused. Your agent can explain why certain homes weren’t on the list to show you – i.e. they don’t match your list, are out of your price range, or have something that you consider a deal breaker. 
  • Avoid becoming an MLS junkie. It’s hard in today’s market to not search the internet to see what’s been newly listed. Just remember to keep it in check and limit the time you spend trying to catch every new listing. You can tell your agent if you’ve seen something that’s a match but don’t become obsessed or anxious about every new listing and second-guess too much.
  • Learn to embrace “good enough.” I do want you to find a home you love. However, no home is going to have everything on your list and still meet your budget. Accept that your decision on a home may come with some sacrifice of a want on your list. Making a choice does mean you’ll be passing up opportunities to look at future listings, but you’ll be stuck “looking forever” and never move into a home. Do you want that to happen?

Let me know if you have any questions about choosing a home and if you’re think you’re afraid you’ll experience choice overload. I definitely recommend reading “The Paradox of Choice” (link to amazon for ordering) for further insight.

Next week is another hot topic for many first-time time buyers. Are you afraid that your student loan is preventing you from becoming a homeowner? Then you’ll love How to Buy a Home with Student Loan Debt, which continues My Dirty Little Secrets to Buying a Home series.


Can you believe it is January 2024 already!

Here is what I talked about in my previous Newsletters.
📌  Is 2024 The Year To Buy A Home?

 📌 4 Little Known House Hunting Tips

📌  Red Flags to Avoid When Buying a Home

📌  What Never To Do Before Buying a Home

📌  How To Go With The Flow Of The Market – Successful Tactics For Buyers

Do you have a specific topic related to real estate that you’d like me to discuss? Let me know by sending me a quick email here! 😉


I'm Catherine and I help international buyers and sellers reach their real estate goals!
Read more about me.

Whether you are a buyer, seller, or investor, we are here to help you! 




Homes you will love



schedule your free consultation

Hi, there!

I'm Catherine Olive and I got into real estate to help foreign nationals, expats and international students navigate the home buying and selling process to avoid challenges I faced due to lack of knowledge. My goal is to make sure that I help you settle and make owning a home in the U.S. a reality.

schedule your free consultation


My Listings


All Articles